Bonnie (boni_bon) wrote in kelly_lims,
Bonnie
boni_bon
kelly_lims


Challenge #1 Results
Eliminations

jane948 with -4 points

Peers Choice
boni_bon with +1 points
hermionesparkle with +1 points

Mods Choice
itsfantastic

Voting Tally
1. -1-1-1-1 = -4
2. +1-1 = 0
3. -1+1+1 = +1
4. +1+1-1 = +1
5. -1-1-1 = -3


Comments
1 -1-1-1-1
I dont like how the lips look. It's okay looking..
I guess I dont really see Kelly like this. The sadness makes me sad I guess.
It doesn't really make sense and the colors are confusing. Is she crying? Are her eyes bleeding?
the effects on her face look really odd, the cropping doesnt look right either.

2 +1-1
the pink blob is distracting and too much text

3 -1+1+1
i love the cropping and the text is really nice.
I like how it has her name is it's very cute.
icon is really oversharpened, cropping is plain.

4 +1+1-1
I actually don't mind this icon, but Its my least favorite out of the three that are left.
Those boxes are cute!
really simple, not oversharpened at all, love the boxes :)

5 -1-1-1
the white block is overpowering
It's too simple
The white box with the heart kind of throws it off. Maybe if the white were a lower opacity, it might be better.

Banners





hermionesparkle will post the next challenge sometime this week :)
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 4 comments